Extinction seems the very epitome of finality and loss, the end of a unique evolutionary history, and the multispecies relationships woven around it. And yet, extinction has also been the inevitable corollary of life as it has unfolded in deep evolutionary time. It is the underside of the dynamic flow of natural variation and adaptation, glimpsed in the archive of the earth’s strata.
Nonetheless, the background extinction rate continues to tick, picking up speed. The current aspect of extinction is that of a human-driven tragedy linked to wanton violence, unbridled extraction, habitat destruction, or even inadvertent circumstance. Mourning species rapidly extinguished by human agency has become a new form of connoisseurship. The ultimate rarities in natural history collections are the worn-out feathers, skins, and bones of the dodo, the thylacine, or the sea cow—relics and silent witnesses to the great acceleration of deaths in the Anthropocene.
The end of the Hoel farm conveys extinction as a multi-species event: not the demise of a single species but a disaster befalling entire networks of living organisms and human communities in place.
Yet, in the case of plants, the perceived finality of extinction belies subtle forms of living on. Afterlives that persist in the lingering abundance of overlooked refugia, the suspended animation of soil seedbanks, or resilient habits of growth that are particular to the being and temporality of plants.
An Arboreal Tale

In general, plants are less prominent in the rhetoric of conservation and extinction. One notable exception is The Overstory, the novel by Richard Powers that won the 2019 Pulitzer Prize in Fiction. An intricate Anthropocene fable about how violence and care are interwoven into our relationship with trees, the book adopts an arboreal structure, with sections titled “Roots,” “Trunk,” “Crown,” and “Seed.”
The first section, “Roots,” is both a gripping introduction to the novel’s development of a botanical imagination and a superb, standalone short story. Named after one of the protagonists, “Nicholas Hoel,” the first chapter is just as much about the American chestnut (Castanea dentata): a tale of botanical generosity and grandeur, destroyed by an imported fungal infection that wipes out America’s “perfect tree.” For as ecologists Edward K. Faison and David R. Foster have argued, the American chestnut is part of an “iconic triumvirate” that also includes the passenger pigeon and the bison, former abundant denizens of the American wilderness that human action pushed to the brink of extinction, or over the cliff.
Powers narrates the American chestnut’s historical retreat from its former territory, ranging from Maine to Mississippi and across the Appalachia, in tandem with the lone survival of a single chestnut carried by the Hoel family to Iowa.

The sometimes synchronous, often asynchronous temporalities of human and plant cycles are central to the chapter, which begins in New York City with the line: “Now is the time of chestnuts.” The present tense of the narrative is a shared moment between plant and human worlds, activated by the trees’ plentiful and effortless harvest.
The abundance raining down from the chestnut trees is an auspicious backdrop to the budding romance between Nicholas Hoel and Vi Powys, soon on their way to the relentless labor and economy of scarcity of the “uncut world” of Iowa. Their settlement on land “platted yesterday” is punctuated by the discovery of six chestnuts forgotten in a coat pocket. Nicholas plants these nuts in his new home, hundreds of miles from the tree’s native range, in hope of securing its abundant gifts for the future.
The fate of the saplings is interwoven with the growing family, the death of the first baby conjoined with one of the six chestnuts’ failure to sprout. The harsh winter of 1862 takes another sapling instead of a child, while a third tree is inadvertently killed by the oldest surviving son in play. A fourth dies of thirst in a drought that almost finishes off the Hoel farm, and one of the last pair is struck by lightning.
The remaining chestnut flourishes in the wake of the Civil War, the two World Wars, and the Vietnam War, even as generations of the Hoel family are interred in a makeshift cemetery at its feet. Without companions, the chestnut continues to flower, but its blooms go unanswered. Chestnuts do not self-pollinate, and Hoel’s visions of a bountiful harvest in Iowa are dashed.
The point is that in its afterlife, the American chestnut is no longer a stately tree of towering grandeur and uncommon bounty. The blight has dethroned the chestnut as forest god, demoting it from charismatic megaflora to tenacious shrub, repeatedly cut down by the blight and resurging from its roots.
The lone survivor stands still while, all around it, a way of life gradually vanishes. The old cycle of planting and harvesting is interrupted by the intrusion of chemical pesticides and patented seeds, until the last holdouts are swallowed up by factory-driven monocultures.
However, this chestnut’s solitary predicament also removes the tree from the sphere of utility and places it in the realm of spiritual and aesthetic meaning. It becomes a landmark, a sentinel, a monument on the flat, undifferentiated landscape.
Sublime Loss

The end of the Hoel farm conveys extinction as a multi-species event: not the demise of a single species but a disaster befalling entire networks of living organisms and human communities in place.
But the text is also haunted by the tree’s transplantation onto the site of earlier erasures. The Hoels’ tenacious and precarious hold on land “platted yesterday” is founded on the removal of indigenous plants and human communities to make space for the newcomers.
Ironically, the chestnuts of the Eastern seaboard supplied abundant, rot-resistant wood for the fences and cabins of the early settlers, before succumbing in their turn to an unexpected intruder.
The isolation of the Hoels’ final chestnut, hundreds of miles from its native range, is a blessing in disguise. For the microscopic decimation of the Hoel grove mirrors the macroscopic disappearance of the native chestnut forest.
Powers recounts the arrival of chestnut blight on board a shipment of Asian stock. Supposedly first detected at the Bronx Zoological Garden in 1904, the blight is a wind-borne fungus that may have been present as early as 1893. This is a quintessential Anthropocene narrative: human actions causing, in the words of Charles Elton, “great historical convulsions in the world’s flora and fauna.” In Powers’ telling, within a year the blight had spread throughout the city, and within a few decades “every fourth tree” of the Eastern forests was “doomed.” In an additional twist, quick logging to salvage the wood may have wiped out those trees that harbored the secret of resistance.
The narrative reaches for the sublime to convey the magnitude of a loss that defies representation: “Four billion trees in the native range vanish into myth” —not mere trees, but dying gods who had dominated the forest canopy and sustained human and more-than-human communities.
Chestnut Myths

Spellbound by Powers’ elegy, I was jolted by an unexpected encounter a few months later, during one of my pandemic walks. Scattered on the ground were several chestnuts sheathed in their distinctive burr, handfuls of them peeking through the grass. They were strewn around some unremarkable trees of a shrubby habit, growing in a nearby national park, with numerous sprouts emerging from their roots.
How could these still be around, given that the American chestnut had vanished into myth?
It turns out that the tree is only “functionally” extinct. Powers discloses as much in the book, the somewhat grudging acknowledgment of the chestnut’s endurance couched as a lament that we will “never see the ripe, full habit of the tree.” “Habit” is used here in its botanical sense of a plant’s living stature, the way the plant grows and holds itself in space. The point is that in its afterlife, the American chestnut is no longer a stately tree of towering grandeur and uncommon bounty. The blight has dethroned the chestnut as forest god, demoting it from charismatic megaflora to tenacious shrub, repeatedly cut down by the blight and resurging from its roots.
The story of the American chestnut may thus be an Anthropocene fable twice over: first as a winner, and then a loser of the Anthropocene.
Yet, as Faison and Foster show, early settler and naturalist accounts, land and forest surveys, and the palaeoecological record challenge the myth that the American chestnut was the dominant tree of the eastern forests before settlers arrived. Indeed, settlers may have been partly responsible for the chestnut’s abundance, as indiscriminate nineteenth-century commercial logging may have allowed the chestnut to rise to prominence, sprouting from cut stumps. In the heavily cut forests of northern New Jersey and southern New England, the chestnut may have increased its prevalence from five to fifteen percent to over fifty percent.
The story of the American chestnut may thus be an Anthropocene fable twice over: first as a winner, and then a loser of the Anthropocene.
Understory Futures

Plants are notoriously difficult to pronounce extinct, reappearing Lazarus-like in fragments of old forest or biding their time in the soil seedbank. What can the afterlife of the American chestnut, beyond what one scholar has called “a memory of abundance,” teach us about the botanical imagination in the present?
On the one hand, Powers’ powerful chestnut elegy invests trees with value. For as Judith Butler has shown, the act of mourning has the power to confer ethical standing to an ever-widening circle of grievable entities.
On the other hand, the stubborn survival of the American chestnut, no longer a charismatic giant of the overstory but a shrub of the understory, points to afterlives that may hold the promise of different futures—perhaps even a future where genetic resistance to the blight may spring from the tree’s tenacity. It diverts us from the finality of extinction to contemplate its many shades—including less poignant but more urgent questions of protecting habitats and genetic diversity.
And it reminds us that finding ways to stay attuned to the different temporalities of plant life is vital to reawakening our aesthetic and ethical responses to the plant world.
Featured Image: Green canopy of an old chestnut tree seen from the ground. Photo by John Reed, 2019.
Yota Batsaki is the executive director of Dumbarton Oaks and principal investigator of the Plant Humanities Initiative. She is coeditor with Anatole Tchikine of Plant Humanities (Harvard University Press, 2026). Her last contribution to Edge Effects was “The Deep Roots of Plant Time.” Contact.





You must be logged in to post a comment.